Will you win or lose with listed property going forward?
PRMonitor:home>>news release>>

Will you win or lose with listed property going forward?

By Harold Strydom: Investment Analyst at Citadel Wealth Management

South African listed property delivered exceptional returns over the last ten years, outperforming both the FTSE/JSE All Share Index (ALSI) and BESA All Bond Index (ALBI), which both had an excellent decade in their own right. With the bar set so high, where to from here for listed property?

Gazing into the future requires us to understand what drove returns over the past decade and then establish how many of these tailwinds will still be evident in the next couple of years. Firstly, however, we need to understand listed property as an asset class.

Owning a house is very different to investing in listed property

For many of us, property is the house we live in and our return is calculated from the purchase price, maintenance and renovations during the years, as well as the eventual selling price. House prices usually rise sharply when the economy is booming and interest rates are low. Shopping malls, office parks or industrial developments, typically owned by listed property companies, should do well under similar economic conditions. However, from a return perspective, the experience of a house owner compared to an investor in listed property shares is very different.

As JSE-listed securities, the prices of these property companies are determined daily by the market. Investors take views on rental growth, vacancies, funding cost and the value of each property to determine what shares are worth. Future acquisitions or developments and concepts like ‘balance sheet gearing’ also drive prices. Importantly, however, investors look at other asset classes like cash, bonds or shares to determine where they will achieve the best future returns.

Property returns driven by falling interest rates

Listed property is predominantly bought for the income distributions (dividends) paid by these companies, and the dividend yield relative to bond yields is an important valuation measure. The fall in interest rates over the last ten years saw property yields declining from above 11% to around 6%. This reduction in yield had a massive positive impact on prices; in fact, this was the largest driver of returns. An important point, which we will get back to, is the question of what lies ahead for bond yields.

Property spreads had a positive impact on price as well

The reduction in property yields is partly due to a large contraction in the property spread, that is, the difference between the property yield and the government bond yield. As investor sentiment towards listed property improved during the past decade, property yields went from higher than bond yields to lower than bond yields; in other words, the spread became negative.

This change provided a further kicker to price returns. In fact, the combination of falling bond yields and contracting spreads caused prices to rise by 14% per year. This is double the 7% per year distributions growth rate. Once again we pose the question, whereto from here for property spreads?

Dividend distributions growth kept pace with inflation

The single best aspect of listed property is that over time, dividend distributions grow roughly in line with inflation. Chart 2 shows that sometimes the growth is faster and sometimes it’s slower, but fact of the matter is that there is a correlation. This is because shopping mall or office rentals typically escalate in line with inflation and, depending on cost control and funding costs (interest rates), this increase is passed through to investors.

This differentiates listed property from a normal government bond where the income (coupon) is fixed. In theory, property can be described as a ‘real’ asset and is more comparable to inflation-linked government bonds. These bonds currently yield around 2%, making listed property yields of more than 6% very attractive. A 6% real return is however only realisable if dividend distributions keep track with inflation going forward.

Our view is that some of the tailwinds are turning into headwinds

Of the three supporting factors we touched on above, we see only one persisting: distributions growing roughly in line with inflation. Interest rates globally are still close to historical lows and are likely to rise in future. If sentiment towards listed property changes in this environment and spreads rise, prices will fall sharply.

It is not difficult to paint a scenario where bond yields rise by 1% and spreads close by 1% (for those that follow the financial press, think tapering by the US Fed faster than currently expected). This 2% change in the yield will instantly knock around 25% off the price of property. The opposite scenario, where yields fall a further 2% from current levels, is however difficult to imagine at this point in time.

The remaining tailwind for listed property, distribution growth, is however extremely powerful. If distributions grow roughly in line with inflation and you have a long (say ten-year) investment horizon, attractive real returns is achievable even in a rising interest rate environment.

It is all about your investment horizon

Our investment conclusion is clear: Investors with a short-term investment horizon that cannot handle volatility should refrain from investing in listed property. The volatility of listed property is almost on par with that of the FTSE/JSE ALSI. We don’t advise anyone who does not have a long-term investment horizon and cannot sit through sharp price falls to invest in shares.

We believe listed property is an important component of a long-term growth portfolio. Even though listed property has different characteristics to shares, you need a similar investment approach.  Currently, we do not hold property in any of our portfolios and prefer to be overweight shares. If our short-term investment view plays out and yields rise to attractive levels, we will definitely be actively looking for an entry point into this market.


Media Release issued: 12 March 2014

About Citadel:

Citadel is a specialist wealth manager with over 20 years’ experience in providing bespoke solutions for high net worth individuals. Through character-rich engagement and building strong relationships based on mutual respect and trust, Citadel enables its clients to explore the true potential of their hard-earned money. The best fiduciary, risk and asset management expertise is used to strategise, implement and manage a financial roadmap for its clients and their family. Visit www.citadel.co.za for more information.


Nasiphi Fazi
Account Executive
Epic Communications (Pty) Ltd
Cape Town: Suite 602, The Regent
19-33 Regent Road, Sea Point
Office: +27 21 439 8008
Mobile: +27 79 380 4816
Follow us on Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/#!/pages/Epic-Communications/161107010567666
Follow us on Twitter: http://www.twitter.com/EpicComms

HTML Comment Box is loading comments...

Get your press releases to the most influential media outlets, editors, journalists, freelancers, news portals, social media networks, bloggers and industry analysts in an instant.

Tell us what you want written and our professional news team will help you reach your goals.

BUSA to seek high level meeting on Eskom power emergency

Business Confidence Claws Back

NAAMSA new vehicle sales drop 3.1% in February

SACCI Copper Theft Barometer up in January

Further Deterioration of Trade Conditions

The Role of NDP in Growing Small Business

Pretoria Zoo crocs get a new reason to smile

Is Price Still King

Half of users believe banks will refund their money in the event of cyber theft

E-tolls must be debated by provincial legislatures

Statement on Forensic Report on Electoral Commision

Local Government Revenue and Expenditure: Second Quarter Local Government Section 71 Report

OPINION: Invoking the wrath of the gods

Nudge: A new communications tactic

PRESS RELEASE: OUTA remains defiant - purchase of e-tags in not law

PRESS RELEASE: UDM reax to Johannesburg

PRESS RELEASE: ANC Gauteng thanks 400 000 residents

PRESS RELEASE: Call to young South Africans: Register to vote!

PRESS RELEASE: Message of support to all learners and students for exams

SPEECH: Can good governance increase trust amongst Govt, CS, Labour and Business?

Pomposity and purple prose

MEDIA ADVISORY: Gordhan to present Budget on February 26

PRESS RELEASE: Minister Gordhan on Mr Mackay's death

PRESS RELEASE: Kumba ICT Concourt judgment

PRESS RELEASE: Minister Patel welcomes High Court decision on scrap metal export system for South Africa

MEDIA ALERT: Gigaba, Nzimande to host intake of 1 000 learner artisans

PRESS RELEASE: COSATU NW on the non-compliances of the municipalities

PRESS RELEASE: SAICA supports the AGSA general report of audit results of national and provincial government

PRESS RELEASE: Joburg Road Closures for the of opening of the Orange AFCON 2013

PRESS RELEASE: Joburg's faith groups urged to support Afcon 2013 through prayer

PRESS RELEASE: Sod turning heralds plans to enhance FNB Stadium pitch

MEDIA ALERT: US Secretary of Commerce launches 'Doing Businesss in Africa' initiative with BUSA

PRESS RELEASE: Statement on Operation "Pillar of Defense" and announcements of countrywide pickets

MEDIA ALERT: Busa to host chairperson of AU Dr Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma

South Africa and Czech Republic recommitted to boost trade relations

SA-EU Business Forum to be inaugurated in Brussels

Improved N14 route between Delareyville and Sannieshof is opened

SANRAL builds roads - and people

N1 Polokwane road closure

OUTA urges MPs to look beyond SANRAL

E-tolls: the system is working but not without some challenges

Platinum mine strike not good for the workers

COSATU response to Public Protector

DA economic policy reinforces apartheid privileges

NUM statement on the State Of The Nation Address

Racism again at Sun International resort

MEDIA ALERT: Start your own business

PRESS ALERT: Financial Co-operatives’ Indaba

PRESS RELEASE: 12 Finalists Announced for the 2012 Africa Awards for Entrepreneurship

PRESS RELEASE: SAA crisis shows why effective succession planning is crucial for SMEs

PRESS RELEASE: Social Enterprises may be SA’s only option

PRESS RELEASE: NUM disappointed as Anglo reinforces boys club mentality

PRESS RELEASE: Tri-partite announcement on Amplats restructuring proposals

Grindrod and Northwest Rail Company partner to develop the Copper Railway in Zambia

New rail leasing entity established for Africa

PRESS RELEASE: Cargo Carriers’ subsidiary brings innovation and reliability to bulk haulage

PRESS RELEASE: Grindrod subsidiary, Vanguard, completes erection of first wind-energy farm

PRESS RELEASE: Grindrod receives green light to acquire RACEC

Agri-Vie Invests $5 Million Into Kariki Group

PRESS RELEASE: Agri-Vie invests 49.9% state in joint Terason and Technichem business

PRESS RELEASE: Agri-Vie announces 63% stake in Cape Olive Holdings

PRESS RELEASE: Agri-Vie invests $6m in Tanzania Food Corporation

PRESS RELEASE: Marel and Three Streams Smokehouse introduce ground-breaking fish processing system

PRESS RELEASE: Awareness vital in preventing onset of heart disease

Cipla Nutrition announces Pain & Gain body makeover competition winner

Setting realistic goals key to keeping 2014 fitness reslotions

PRESS RELEASE: Joshua Capazorio chooses Cipla Nutrition

PRESS RELEASE: Cipla Medpro 'Ajuga' to address South Africa's shack fire crisis

PRESS RELEASE: SA pharmacists support greater public-private collaboration - survey

PRESS RELEASE: Smart tips for festive savings this Christmas

Orion Group finishes 2013 with double-digit growth in Hotel Division

Limited trade commences in Vodacom YeboYethu Scheme

Vodacom comment on ICASA termination rate statement

PRESS RELEASE: Vodacom recognised as Best Performer on JSE SRI Index

PRESS RELEASE: Interim results for the six months ended 30 September 2013

PRESS RELEASE: Vodacom supports reduction in mobile termination rates, raises concerns on asymmetry

Nedbank appoints Epic Communications as its PR agency

Nedbank Fair Share 2030 starts with Targeted Lending of R6 billion

PRESS RELEASE: Absa named South Africa’s best bank in Service Excellence

PRESS RELEASE: Armien Tyer to join Absa as Head of Investments

PRESS RELEASE: Absa multi-currency travel card uptake at 77%

PRESS RELEASE: IBM appoints ICT Worx as the first IBM Authorised Training Partner

PRESS RELEASE: PBT Group expands

PRESS RELEASE: Samsung cloud strategy driven by access devices

PRESS RELEASE: The African potential for tablets

PRESS RELEASE: Samsung inks a trendsetting smart solutions partnership deal with the Rwanda Government

PRESS RELEASE: RGT Smart appoints new financial director

RGT Smart appoints new financial director

Copyright | Terms of Service